$3.5 Million Riverside County Wrongful Death Lawsuit Reached in Excessive Use of Police Force Fatality
The family of Arthur Lewis, Jr. has reached a $3.55 million California wrongful death settlement with Riverside County. The Moreno Valley man died in 2003 after sheriff's deputies wrestled him to the ground and pepper-sprayed him. His parents had called 911 for medical help because the 33-year-old US Navy veteran refused to take his anti-anxiety medication or eat.
The deputy who arrived at the scene called for assistance because he thought Lewis would resist. One officer is accused of attempting a carotid restraint on him for at least 20 seconds and he was reportedly slammed onto the ground with his face down. A police dog was brought into the home, forcing Lewis' parents into another room.
While restrained, Lewis stopped breathing. The deputies performed CPR while waiting for medical assistance. Lewis was pronounced dead at the hospital.
Lewis's family originally tried to settle their Riverside County wrongful death case for $475,000, but the board of supervisors refused. Last year, a jury awarded the Moreno Valley man's family members $5.5 million and accused the deputies of negligence and excessive police force. However, because they determined that Lewis was partially responsible, the amount was lowered by 20%. An appeal was filed.
Now, Lewis' parents will get $575,000 each while his two children will receive $1.2 million each.
Law enforcement officers have a responsibility to refrain from using excessive force when dealing with the public. Excessive police force can cause serious injuries and even death. Granted, in many instances, the deputies or officers likely did not intend to cause harm to the victim. They may be responding in the moment and trying to deal with what they perceive to be a frightening or a dangerous situation. This, however, does not give them the right to use Riverside County police brutality or excessive use of force.
Family to get $3.5 million in death of man restrained by sheriff's deputies in Moreno Valley, Los Angeles Times, July 17, 2010
Riverside County settles for $3.55 million in Moreno Valley wrongful death suit, The Press-Enterprise, July 16, 2010
Related Web Resources:
Moreno Valley Police
Excessive force cases often full of ambiguity, KnoxNews, December 3, 2007